Pipe Relining vs Pipe Replacement

23 hours plumbing van

In the realm of plumbing woes, there's nothing quite as anxiety-inducing as a damaged or broken pipe. It's a situation that can disrupt your daily life, damage your property, and leave you with an unexpected financial burden.

Thankfully, two primary solutions are available to address this issue: pipe relining and traditional pipe replacement.

So, if you’re facing pipe problems and want to make an informed choice, keep reading.

Understanding Pipe Relining

Pipe relining is a modern, trenchless method that has revolutionised the world of plumbing and become the “best alternative” solution. It offers an efficient, cost-effective solution for repairing damaged pipes without extensive digging. Here’s a breakdown of the pipe relining process:

  1. Pipe inspection: The process begins with thoroughly inspecting the existing pipe using CCTV drain cameras. This step allows plumbers to pinpoint the exact location and nature of the damage, whether it’s due to tree roots, cracks, or other issues.
  2. Pipe cleaning: After identifying the problem areas, high-pressure water jet technology is employed to clean the inside of the damaged pipe, ensuring a smooth surface for the relining process.
  3. Pipe relining: A flexible, seamless liner coated with epoxy resin is inserted into the damaged pipe. This liner adheres to the pipe walls, creating a durable, leak-free inner layer.
  4. Curing: To solidify the epoxy resin and ensure structural integrity, compressed air or hot water cures the liner. This results in a brand-new pipe within the old one, effectively repairing the damage.

Advantages of Pipe Relining

There are many benefits to pipe relining over full excavation and pipe replacement, including:

  • Minimal disruption: Pipe relining is a trenchless method requiring significantly less excavation than pipe replacement. This translates to minimal disruption to your property. Your garden, driveway, or landscaping remains intact, saving you from costly restoration work.
  • Speedy repairs: Pipe relining is a swift process. In most cases, it can be completed within a day, reducing the inconvenience caused by plumbing issues. Traditional replacement, on the other hand, can take several days or even weeks.
  • Long-lasting solution: The epoxy resin liner used in pipe relining enhances the pipe’s structural integrity. It creates a durable and leak-free inner layer that can withstand future damage, ensuring a long-lasting solution.
  • Cost-effective: While pipe relining may seem more expensive upfront than traditional methods, it is often more cost-effective in the long run. The reduced need for excavation and restoration, coupled with the longevity of the relined pipe, can lead to cost savings over time.
  • Preservation of landscape: Since pipe relining requires minimal digging, your outdoor landscape remains undisturbed. This preservation of your property’s aesthetics is a significant advantage.
  • Versatility: Pipe relining suits various pipe materials, including clay, PVC, cast iron, and more. It can also repair pipes of varying diameters, making it a versatile solution for different plumbing systems.

Pipe relining, Pipe Replacement

Disadvantages of Pipe Relining

While it’s often recommended, there are some disadvantages to pipe relining, including:

  • Initial cost: The upfront cost of pipe relining can be higher than traditional methods. However, it’s essential to consider the long-term savings and benefits when evaluating the overall cost.
  • Limited application: While pipe relining is suitable for many situations, it may not be feasible in some cases. Severe pipe damage or specific pipe configurations may require traditional replacement.
  • Professional expertise required: Pipe relining is a specialised technique that requires trained and experienced plumbers. Hiring a reputable and skilled relining specialist is crucial to ensure the process is done correctly.
  • Curing time: The epoxy resin liner needs time to cure and harden after relining. This downtime can inconvenience homeowners, although it is usually brief compared to the longer duration required for traditional replacement.
  • Pipe diameter restrictions: Extremely narrow or large pipes may not be suitable for relining. Plumbers will assess the feasibility of relining based on the specific pipe’s dimensions.

Relined pipes offer numerous advantages, including minimal disruption, speedy repairs, and long-lasting results. However, it’s essential to consider factors such as the initial cost and the method’s suitability for your specific plumbing issue.

Consulting with experienced professionals will help you make an informed decision and ensure the successful repair of your damaged pipes.

Traditional Pipe Replacement Methods

In contrast to pipe relining, traditional pipe replacement involves digging up the damaged pipe and replacing it with a new one. Here’s how it typically unfolds:

  1. Excavation: The process begins with excavating the area around the damaged pipe, which can be costly and disruptive, especially if the pipe is located beneath driveways, gardens, or buildings.
  2. Removing the old pipe: Once the damaged pipe is exposed, it is removed, and a new pipe is installed.
  3.  Restoration: After the new pipe is in place, the excavated area must be restored, which can involve concrete cutting, replacing retaining walls, and other costly tasks.

Pros of Traditional Pipe Replacement

There are some advantages to traditional pipe replacement, such as:

  • Guaranteed new pipes: Traditional pipe replacement involves removing the old, damaged pipes and replacing them with brand-new ones. This ensures that you have a completely fresh and reliable plumbing system.
  • Suitable for severe damage: Traditional replacement may be the only viable option in cases of extensive or severe damage to the pipes. It allows for completely removing the damaged sections, preventing further issues.
  • Long-term solution: Traditional replacement can be long-lasting, especially when high-quality materials are used. This can offer peace of mind, knowing you won’t have to address plumbing issues in the same area for many years.
  • Versatility: Traditional replacement can be applied to various pipe materials, making it suitable for multiple plumbing systems. It can also accommodate different pipe diameters and configurations.
  • Customisation: When replacing pipes traditionally, you can upgrade your plumbing system or make modifications to suit your specific needs. Expanding your property or updating your plumbing infrastructure can be beneficial.

Pipe relining, Pipe Replacement

Cons of Traditional Pipe Replacement

Here’s the downside to the traditional method of replacing pipes:

  • Extensive disruption: Traditional pipe replacement typically involves digging up the damaged pipes, which can be extremely disruptive and damaging to your property. This may include excavating driveways, gardens, or even parts of buildings.
  • Time-consuming: Traditional replacement is often a time-consuming process. It can take several days to complete when you may be without essential plumbing services. This can be inconvenient and costly.
  • Higher costs: Due to the excavation, removal of old pipes, and restoration work required, traditional pipe replacement is generally more expensive upfront compared to trenchless methods like relining.
  • Property damage: The excavation process can lead to damage beyond the plumbing system itself. This may include repairing driveways, landscaping, or other structures, increasing costs.
  • Environmental impact: Traditional pipe replacement can have a more significant environmental impact due to the excavation and disposal of old pipes. It may also disrupt local ecosystems.
  • Inconvenience: The disruption caused by traditional replacement can be highly inconvenient for homeowners, potentially requiring them to vacate their properties temporarily.

Traditional pipe replacement offers the advantage of guaranteeing new pipes and is suitable for severe damage. However, it has significant drawbacks, including extensive disruption, higher costs, and longer project timelines.

When deciding between traditional replacement and alternative methods like pipe relining, it’s crucial to consider your plumbing needs, budget, and tolerance for disruption. Consulting with experienced plumbers will help you make an informed choice tailored to your circumstances.

Making an Informed Choice

Several factors come into play when choosing between pipe relining and traditional pipe replacement. The decision should be based on the damage’s extent, the pipe’s location, and your budget.

For minor to moderate damage inaccessible areas, pipe relining is a cost-effective and efficient choice. However, traditional replacement may be the only option in severely damaged pipes or hard-to-reach locations.

Get Your Pipes Sorted Today with 23 Hour Plumbing!

Understanding the differences between a pipe relining solution and a traditional pipe replacement option is crucial when facing plumbing issues. Both methods have their merits, but pipe relining is often more efficient and cost-effective thanks to its trenchless nature and long-lasting results.

Ultimately, consulting with licensed plumbers specialising in these techniques is the best way to determine the right approach for your specific needs.

In the world of plumbing, choosing between a pipe relining method and replacement can be a tough decision. But here at 23 Hour Plumbing, we make it easy for you.

Our team of experts is ready to tackle your plumbing needs for repairing pipes, and we’ve got the skills and know-how to provide competitive cost services that will leave your plumbing in tip-top shape.

Don’t let broken pipes disrupt your life – reach out to us today and experience the difference. Your pipes will thank you for it!

Please note: This information is provided for advice purposes only. Regulations differ from state to state, so please consult your local authorities or an industry professional before proceeding with any work. See 23 Hour Plumbing’s Terms & Conditions here.

Last Edited on: 29th September 2023

Need a Plumber?

Local Plumbers available 24/7

Recent Posts

Noticing some strange issues with your plumbing? It could be a sign of a failing ...

No one wants their sleep interrupted by the sound of a constant dripping tap in ...

Learn about the process of drain excavation for clearing blockages that can’t be cleared any ...

Blocked drains or a loss of hot water? 23 Hour Plumbing is ready to help ...

Running a gas heater, stove or hot water system in your home? Any gas appliance ...